World Rugby

Irish Rugby Flyhalf Legacy: Crowley, Frawley, Prendergast Battle for #10

Irish Rugby Flyhalf Legacy: Crowley, Frawley, Prendergast Battle for #10

Battle for Ireland's No. 10 jersey heats up with Jack Crowley, Ciaran Frawley and Sam Prendergast, as they follow Kyle, O'Gara, and Johnny Sexton.

Oct 23, 2024 by Philip Bendon
null

The Irish Rugby number ten shirt has always been a coveted and fiercely contested position, symbolizing both brilliance and immense pressure. 

Over the years, one player typically dominated this role, but the challengers were never far behind. This singular position has seen promising careers flourish or fade depending on the individual’s ability to consistently prove themselves in the crucible of international rugby. Unlike other nations, Irish rugby tends to stick with its chosen flyhalf, giving them time to develop, even in the face of mounting competition. And while Ireland's World Cup success may not reflect the dominance some might hope for, the individuals who have worn the ten jersey have consistently taken the team to new heights. 

The flyhalf fascination truly began in the 1940s with the enigmatic Jackie Kyle. Known for his free-spirited approach to the game, Kyle enchanted fans across Ireland. His wizardry on the field often led to poetic match reports rather than just factual accounts. One of his most famous moments came against France in Belfast, prompting a journalist to write, “They seek him here, they seek him there. Those Frenchies seek him everywhere. That paragon of pace and guile. That damned elusive Jackie Kyle.”

Fast-forward twenty years, and two Dubliners—Tony Ward and Ollie Campbell—would engage in a duel for the number ten jersey, a rivalry that would shape Irish rugby for years. Ward, known for his heroic performance in Munster’s legendary win over the All Blacks, was also a prolific point scorer for both Ireland and the British and Irish Lions. His crowning international moment came when he scored the winning points against France in 1988, securing Ireland’s first win in France since 1972. Ward’s performances were so remarkable that he was named the first-ever European Player of the Year in 1979.


null

However, despite Ward’s achievements, it was Campbell who would go on to be remembered by many as the more iconic player. Regarded as the most well rounded Irish flyhalf since Jackie Kyle, Campbell orchestrated Ireland’s 1982 Triple Crown win—their first in 30 years—and followed it up with another Five Nations title a year later.


The Rise Of Ronan O'Gara For Ireland Rugby

By the late 1990s, Irish rugby found itself in the midst of another flyhalf battle, this time between the experienced David Humphreys and the up-and-coming Ronan O’Gara. Humphreys, known for his gentlemanly demeanour, had led Ulster to a European Cup triumph in 1999 and was determined to hold off the challenge from O’Gara. But by 2000, O’Gara had claimed the number ten shirt and, alongside the likes of Brian O’Driscoll and Paul O’Connell, helped transform Irish rugby from European also-rans to genuine contenders. 

O’Gara’s era was one of unparalleled success. He led Munster to two Heineken Cup titles and famously kicked the winning drop goal to secure Ireland’s first Six Nations Grand Slam in 60 years in 2009. He was named in the team of the decade and earned the prestigious honor of best player in European rugby’s first 15 years. 

Here Comes Johnny Sexton

As O’Gara’s illustrious career was winding down, another contender—Jonathan Sexton—was waiting in the wings. Like O’Gara, Sexton’s ascent was marked by a defining moment: the 2009 Heineken Cup semi-final, where he guided Leinster to their first-ever European title, dethroning Munster in the process. This match, in front of a record crowd at Croke Park, signalled a changing of the guard. Over the next decade, Sexton would go on to achieve even greater success than his predecessor, winning four Heineken Cups, five Six Nations titles, and the World Player of the Year award in 2018. 

With Johnny Sexton Retired, Who Takes For Ireland Rugby?

When Sexton’s career ended in heartbreak at the 2023 Rugby World Cup quarterfinal, it was clear that replacing such an iconic figure would be a monumental task. But unlike in previous eras, Irish rugby was ready for the challenge. Emerging as the frontrunner was Munster’s Jack Crowley, who had already guided Ireland to a Six Nations title and helped secure a series draw against the reigning world champion Springboks in South Africa. Crowley hailed as a prodigy from his schoolboy days, has been a key figure for head coach Andy Farrell, though he’s aware that consistency remains the key to unlocking his full potential. 

However, Crowley is not alone in the battle for the ten jersey. Leinster’s Ciaran Frawley has proven his mettle with late-game heroics, including two crucial drop goals against South Africa, and boasts the physicality, confidence, and rugby intelligence needed for the role. Then there’s the young phenom Sam Prendergast, who is widely considered the future of Irish rugby. At just 21, Prendergast was the standout player in the U20 Six Nations and the U20 World Championship. Many believe he has the potential to not only be the best flyhalf Ireland has ever produced but to become the best in the world.

For the first time in Irish rugby history, the battle for the number ten shirt is truly wide open, with multiple contenders already capable of performing at the highest level. As the next chapter in this storied position unfolds, the competition is set to intensify, setting the stage for what could be a decade-long rivalry between three world-class talents.

How To Watch Rugby Matches In the United States On FloRugby

FloRugby and FloSports also are the U.S. home to: 

FloRugby also is home to match archives and match replays. 

Join The Rugby Conversation On FloRugby Social